Frogacuda wrote:Look, it's going to be cheesy either way, but if it's cheesy in a fun way, people will enjoy it, and if it's cheesy and serious, it will just come off melodramatic and won't appeal to anyone.
Don't get me wrong, I want the humour! Like I said "Tex can be funny without being cheesy". I guess I just dislike that term "cheesy". The Tex games have a wonderful variety of humor and "cheesy" feels to me like a bit of a dishonour to the great comedic timing of Chris and Aaron's great humour in his writing etc.
Definition of "cheesy":
Cheap, unpleasant, poor quality, shoddy or blatantly inauthentic
Tex needs to be somewhat comfortable with its B-movie vibe, and play that up as a strength, because it's stuck with it either way.
I wouldn't consider Tex games as having a "B-movie" vibe, or at least in later games they seemed to get stronger in this sense including Chris himself getting stronger and stronger as Tex. From interviews Chris/Aaron seem to say they improved "geometrically". I agree I wouldn't want it to be overly serious and Pandora seemed to strike some balance. I like Under A Killing Moon though. I want to see another funny piano song from Chris
Also, I don't know why you think hardcore Tex fans are the only ones who like to laugh. Gaming's lost it's sense of humor in recent years, and the games that defy that, like Portal 2 or Double Fine's games, are always warmly met by critics and fans alike.
I think they'd be really disappointed if we got a deadly serious game.
I would be dissapointed too and I certainly don't think Tex fans are the only ones who would want to laugh.... I guess I came across wrong. As I said I want the humour. I liked the great comedy moments in UAKM like Tex throwing his gun out the window etc. I loved the balance between comedy and drama too in Pandora and its great that there will be more humour, like what was in the Radio Theater etc. I enjoy adventure games with humour like Monkey Island, Space Quest etc. I guess I am just curious how it will be implemented and I think there can be discussion/debate on that point without necessarily having it mean the idea itself is wrong.
sam10100 wrote:I think the AC&CJ know how to balance the best of both worlds (drama and humor).
I agree, but still was kinda curious on specifics. I guess curiosity killed the cat though...
Anyway I love comedy "unlikely" detectives like Columbo, Inspector Clouseau and Murder She Wrote etc. Its just they dont tend to break into song so I wondered how itd be woven in. As others say it'd fit nicely as a easter egg or something. I did say a few times you could be investigating a trash can and have it trigger and that it'd be funny if so. So I did consider something along the lines of the basketball scene etc. I'm really sorry if it came across like I was saying "OMG DONT FRIGGIN PUT THAT IN I POO POO ON THAT IDEA. &%!* LETS GET SERIOUS GAWD!"

....
As I'm not the only one curious I figure it's a good question for the countdown questions round, if people know how it'll be placed in the game maybe more would pledge up for it at the last moment if they are on the fence about it? Some are curious in the Kickstarter comments too.
Frank wrote:I'm guilty of pushing for a musical number every chance I had.
Let's make this happen!
Don't feel guilty. I'm truly truly sorry. It seems like I've come across all wrong?
It's a great idea that is getting people to up their pledges what could be bad about that? I was just curious on the implementation really...
I mean I did do Avenue Q musical lyrics with Rook and Clint above

I'm a bit dissapointed noone's commented on that actually haha. I havent actually seen Avenue Q though except on Youtube since it doesnt tour here but it looks great. Also I went to Spamalot the Musical (and I had to walk through one of the worst blizzards in UK history to get to it too) so I do like funny musicals
